Atlantis Pizzeria: Original New York-Style Pies on South Congress Avenue

On South Congress Avenue in Atlantis, Atlantis Pizzeria has kept its pitch simple for years: "Original New York-Style Pizza," made the way it's supposed to be made, with a menu built for both loyal regulars and pizza purists moving down from up north.

Classic Pies, Straightforward Pricing

The menu covers the range guests expect from a proper New York-style pizzeria, starting with a classic cheese pizza and extending into specialty options like a Meat Lovers pie loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and meatball, and a Greek Pizza finished with kalamata olives, feta, and olive oil. For guests with dietary restrictions, the pizzeria also offers a gluten-free cauliflower crust alternative — a detail that broadens who can actually enjoy the menu without leaving anyone stuck ordering a salad.

A Reputation Built Slice by Slice

Atlantis Pizzeria has earned a strong reputation among online pizza-ordering audiences, with reviewers frequently praising the consistency of the food — one visitor specifically noted the restaurant's "consistent great food," while transplants from New York have singled out the pizza as a genuine taste of home. The pizzeria operates primarily on delivery and pickup, and offers a discount for guests who order directly through its website rather than through third-party apps.

For a straightforward, no-nonsense New York-style pizza fix in the Atlantis area, this South Congress Avenue spot delivers exactly what its name promises.

Good to Know: Atlantis Pizzeria is located at 5925 S Congress Ave, Atlantis, FL 33462. Delivery and pickup are available daily. Call (561) 965-3330 to place an order.